Singhasan Battisi · Chapter 22

Anuparekha: The Guardian of Nature and Learning

·Singhasan Battisi·2 min read
From the series
Singhasan Battisi
Text size

At the twenty-second step, Anuparekha asked whether wisdom comes from birth or teaching. Vikram and his chief minister had once argued over the same question. The minister believed earlier tendencies fixed a person’s intelligence; Vikram insisted that what children hear, see, and practise also shapes them. They agreed to examine the question rather than win it with words.

In the old telling, Vikram arranged for four infants—a prince and the sons of a minister, a city guard, and a Brahmin—to be raised in a secluded forest house. Their nurses could feed and protect them but could not speak or hear, so no child learned his family’s occupation or rank. Guards kept the place free from visitors and even loud public sounds. This severe experiment lasted twelve years.

Anuparekha: The Guardian of Nature and Learning — illustration

When the families longed to see the children, Vikram ended the isolation and brought them to court. All four had grown without ordinary language and community, yet their gestures and early responses differed. Courtiers used these differences to argue that birth alone had decided everything.

Vikram saw a more complicated lesson. The children’s isolation had also limited all of them; silence was not a fair education. Whatever tendencies they carried needed language, affection, teachers, companions, and choice in order to develop fully. He acknowledged that the test could not justify denying any child those things again.

He reunited the children with their families, provided patient teachers, and asked what each wished to learn once they could communicate. He told the court that inherited tendencies may offer a beginning, while environment, opportunity, effort, and judgment influence the path. Evidence should improve care, not become a cage.

Anuparekha: The Guardian of Nature and Learning — illustration

“No child should be trapped by a prediction about birth,” he concluded. “A fair kingdom gives every child room to grow.”

Anuparekha asked Bhoj, “Will you look beyond ancestry and invest in possibility?” Bhoj lowered his foot.

Moral: Inborn tendencies matter, but care, learning, and choices shape what a person becomes.

The moral of the tale

Inborn tendencies matter, but care, learning, and choices shape what a person becomes.